- On starting a new game, I don't think you can pick up any jigsaw pieces before you get to the arcade.
- This guide is accurate as of 7th April 2024.
Fun District
John Johnny's (Hotel) (6 Puzzle Pieces, 2 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- Immediately after helping Pat unlock his room at 10am, you'll be returned to the hotel lobby. At this point, you can find a puzzle piece at Pat's vacated table.
- In the stack of cups on the bar counter.
- In the chandelier.
- Speak to Nervous Derry in the lobby when Pat calls you to the hotel at 4pm, before going up to Pat's room.
- You'll receive one puzzle piece automatically after helping Pat at 4pm.
- After guiding Pat through the halls of the hotel, there's a puzzle piece on the dessert that appears.
Family Members
- Pat, automatically, during your first playthrough.
- Nervous Derry. Speak to him at the bar at 4pm.
Outside (6 Puzzle Pieces, 2 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- On the click up and down sign.
- On the Brodega sign.
- On the flower sign, right under the John Johnnies Hotel sign. You'll need to click and drag your way up the area to see it.
- At night, speak to Sleazarius multiple times.
- At night, check the mailbox.
- At night, speak to Fifthwilliam the Fourth four times. He's hiding on the balcony.
Family Members
- Slick Mickey (Three Card Mickey)
- Lovely Maria (Family History Mystery). You don't need to put all the pictures into place to complete the game, that's just for you.
Adelaide's Arcade (5 Puzzle Pieces, 2 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- On the skeeball machine in the back.
- On the controls for Vampire Punter D.
- Speak to Artie multiple times. He's hiding behind the curtain on the left.
- Inside the claw machine, during Round 3 of Claw School (see below).
- Beat The Ol' Pinny B. Speak to Joanie to play (see below).
Family Members
- Joanie (The Ol' Pinny B). Score over 15,000 points for the Pinball Lizard achievement.
- I struggled a lot with this. If you get over 5000 points, quit out with Alt+F4 or you won't be able to play again that day. You can nudge the machine by pressing B which might get you a few extra buttons if you can get the ball to hit the points bells things a few times.
- Sweet Geraldine (Claw School). You can get the We're Best Friends! achievement by picking up both the Baman and Piderman figurines in the final round.
Trolley (1 Puzzle Piece, 2 Family Members)
Puzzle Piece
- Click on the trolley map above the door.
Family Members
- Baby-Faced Constance (Older Maid). She will randomly appear when you ride the Trolley around town. You may need to have beaten Nanna Rue at Old Maid first.
- Good Ole Clancy (A Streetcar Maimed his Flier). He's in the engine room, which you can access after meeting Old Constance. There are three puzzles to complete, once you've found enough jigsaw pieces for each one. The first unlocks District 9, the second gives you his photo, and the third is just for fun.
Alligator Memorial Park (4 Puzzle Pieces, 5 Family Members)
Puzzle Piece
- Fountain.
- Tip of the gazebo.
- Bridge.
- Eat-mergency sign.
- Speak to Theresa (on the bench in front of Two Ton Tony) until she hands it over. For me, that only happened the second time I exhausted her dialogue.
Family Members
- Skids Valentino (Hide and Sheesh). You won't see your lives being lost during the game.
- Gentle Lorenzo (Flappy Bro).
- Two Ton Tony (Manic Pixie Dream Grill).
- Giovanni (Hooked on Tonics).
- Tin Lizzy (Unmix the Pix).You can obtain the Solid Snake achievement in round 3 if the photo of Aidan in his stone form appears. I think it's luck-based whether it does or not, and I think you may have had to have lost Aidan's minigame in this playthrough for it to appear.
Downtown
Outside (5 Puzzle Pieces, 7 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- Click on the eye in the 'Nana Pine's' sign.
- Dumpster in front of Nana Pine's antiques.
- Window in the top right.
- Complete Make My Wife, Please for Papouli without skipping.
- Speak to Sleepy Pants, in the car. You'll need to exhaust his dialogue on two occasions.
Family Members
- Papouli (Make My Wife, Please). This is a sliding puzzle game. You can take as much time and as many moves as you like, though the game will offer to let you skip. With these puzzles, I generally put them together row-by-row, from top to bottom. Once a row is in place, I picture it as a little train, with carriages that have to follow each other. When you need to move a piece out of the way, move the whole train as one and then move it back. This may not be the quickest or most efficient method, but it works.
- Mona the Snipper (Smells Like Zine Spirit). You need to put Mona's 'zine together in such a way that the three topics - social issues, indie comics, and K-pop - are evenly covered. Dad's photo is received automatically with Mona's.
- Denise, Maurice, Patrice, and Luis (Barbershop Upset).
Antique Shop (4 Puzzle Pieces, 4 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- Safe in the top left.
- Cash register.
- Crossed swords above Nana Rue.
- Matryoshka dolls, to the right of the screen.
Family Members
- Nana Rue (Old Maid). This is entirely luck-based.
- The Black Widow (The Bargain of Earthly Defrights). You need to find the ghost through the planchette and then stay on him. Her suspicion raises when the planchette isn't on him and lowers when it is. You'll also receive The White Widower's photo automatically.
- Diamond Alice (Flours of Annoy). She's hopping around the bottom of the screen. Her minigame is very forgiving.
Back Room (3 Puzzle Pieces, 1 Family Member)
Puzzle Pieces
- On the phone.
- On the mirror.
- On the lampshade.
Family Members
- Click on the baby monitor on the shelves for Angelface (Watch a Totally Normal Baby). You receive the Love that Baby achievement if you complete the minigame without letting any ghosts through.
- This was the most difficult achievement for me. To practice multiple times in a row, you'll need to shut the game down when you lose or win but with a ghost having gotten through. Use Alt+F4, then open it up and have another go.
Unsavoury Part of Town
Outside (3 Puzzle Pieces, 3 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- Very Adult Bar sign.
- Rubbish in the alleyway.
- Drain in the road.
Family Members
- Prince and Princess Valentino (Divine Twinteritance). The twins will tell you whether they like the item or not and you can switch your choices as much as you like.
- Aidan (Meditation Infestation). To get the achievement associated with this (AHH THE BEES! THE BEES ARE IN MY EYES--) stay on the screen with the stone form of Aidan after losing. Flies, bees, and butterflies will keep appearing, and you'll have eight bees on screen in 2-3 minutes. To get the other achievement, Solid Snake, play Tin Lizzie's minigame after losing this one, and stop on the photo of Aidan and Lizzie in the third round.
Very Adult Bar (4 Puzzle Pieces, 3 Family Members)
Puzzle Pieces
- Exit sign.
- Bar stool.
- Left toilet door.
- "Sippy Cups" sign above the toilets.
Family Members
- Tall Jared (Ghost in the Cell). If you click on the video app six times, you'll get the Screen Time achievement.
- The Knife (Mack that Knife). You'll receive the Sotenbori Memorial achievement if you choose the best options, i.e., the ones that make little hearts appear. If you want a hint, he likes flowers. If you just want the answers, they're:
- Botanical Garden
- Flowers
- Somewhere Cool
- Shiny Scales
- Carnival Games
- Bobby Blue Eyes (Knife to Meet You).
Girls, Girls, Girls (3 Puzzle Pieces)
- One automatically, on entry.
- On the clock.
- Speak to Sal three times.
District 9 (3 Puzzle Piece, 2 Family Members)
Puzzle Piece
- Inside the train cabin.
- Read the note on the floor.
- Barrier at the end of the track.
Family Members
- Gary the Nose (Artist's Ally). If you struggle, there's a guide here.
- Big Mama (Oldest Maid).
